All posts
Food nutrition facts

Protein milk vs regular milk: 13 g vs 8 g per cup

Macroji

Protein milk is regular cow's milk that's been filtered to concentrate the protein and remove some of the sugar. Most filtered milks list about 13 g of protein per cup on the label, against about 8 g in regular milk, with around half the sugar. Calories are similar to regular milk of the same fat level. It costs more, so whether it's worth it depends on how hard you find it to hit your protein.

You'll see it sold as "protein milk", "high-protein milk", "filtered" or "ultra-filtered" milk. They're all the same idea.

How protein milk is made

Milk is passed through very fine filters. Water and some of the lactose (milk sugar) pass through, and the protein, calcium and fat stay behind. The milk is then mixed back to a normal fat level. The result is milk with more protein and less sugar in each cup. Most brands also add lactase, the enzyme that breaks down lactose, so many filtered milks are lactose-free.

It's still dairy. Filtering doesn't remove the milk proteins, so it isn't suitable for anyone with a milk allergy.

Protein milk vs regular milk

Regular milk, 1 cupCalProteinCarbs
Whole (3.25%)1468 g11.3 g
2%1228.2 g12 g
1%1058.2 g12.6 g
Skim838.4 g12 g

A cup is 244 g. Regular milk's carbs are almost all lactose, its natural sugar. Fat level changes the calories a lot, but the protein barely moves: every type has about 8 g a cup. Whole milk vs skim compares the four types in full.

Filtered protein milk, by comparison, usually lists around 13 g of protein and 6 g of sugar per cup on its label, at roughly the same calories as regular milk with the same fat. Check your carton; brands differ.

So the trade is: about 5 g more protein and about 6 g less sugar per cup, for a higher price.

Is protein milk worth it?

It's worth it if you drink a lot of milk and struggle to hit your protein. Two cups a day of protein milk instead of regular adds about 10 g of protein with no extra calories, which is roughly a third of a chicken breast's protein.

It's not worth it if you only use a splash in coffee, or you already hit your protein easily. At a splash, the extra protein is tiny. Regular milk is still a good, nutritious food.

For comparison, nonfat Greek yogurt gives about 25 g of protein per cup, and a scoop of whey about 23 to 27 g. If protein is your goal, those do more per calorie. Protein milk's advantage is that it's a drink you'd have anyway.

Protein milk for weight loss

On a calorie deficit, the best protein milk is the skim or 1% version, since fat is where most of milk's calories come from. Good ways to use it:

Protein milk for bulking

On a bulk, whole-milk protein milk is an easy way to add calories and protein without more food. A big glass with each meal adds up quickly. Regular whole milk does almost the same job for less money, so it's a fine choice too.

Milk is one of the 30 staples in the clean eating meal plan. Any version works there; protein milk is an upgrade, not a requirement.

Protein milk vs plant milks

Most plant milks have much less protein than cow's milk. Unsweetened almond milk has under 1 g per 100 g and oat milk about the same. Unsweetened soy milk is the exception, at about 3.5 g per 100 g, close to dairy. If you're dairy-free, soy milk or a plant milk with added pea protein is the closest swap.

Logging protein milk

For plant milks compared with each other, including barista oat milk, see oat milk vs almond milk.

Frequently asked questions

What is protein milk?

Cow's milk that has been filtered through fine membranes to remove some water and lactose, which concentrates the protein. Most filtered milks list about 13 g of protein per cup, against about 8 g in regular milk, with around half the sugar.

Does protein milk have more calories than regular milk?

Not much. Calories are similar to regular milk with the same fat level, because the extra protein replaces some of the sugar. Check your carton, since brands differ.

Is protein milk worth it?

If you drink a lot of milk and struggle to hit your protein, yes: two cups a day adds about 10 g of protein with no extra calories. If you only use a splash in coffee, the difference is small and regular milk is fine.

Is protein milk lactose-free?

Many are. Filtering removes some lactose and most brands add lactase to break down the rest. It is still dairy, so it is not suitable for anyone with a milk allergy.

How much protein is in regular milk?

About 8 g per cup (244 g), whether it is whole, 2%, 1% or skim. The fat level changes the calories, from about 83 for skim to 146 for whole, but not the protein.