All posts
Food nutrition facts

What are sugar alcohols? Erythritol, xylitol and more

Macroji

What is a sugar alcohol, in short: sugar alcohols (also called polyols) are sweeteners such as erythritol, xylitol, sorbitol and maltitol that taste like sugar but aren't fully absorbed, so they have fewer calories (0.2 to 2.6 per gram, against sugar's 4) and raise blood sugar less. Despite the name, they contain no alcohol. Their main downside is digestive: in larger amounts they can cause bloating, gas and diarrhea. Erythritol is the best tolerated and has almost no calories. Below is how each one compares, how to count them, and whether they're bad for you.

What are sugar alcohols?

Sugar alcohols are carbohydrates whose chemical structure is part sugar, part alcohol, which is where the name comes from. They don't contain ethanol, the alcohol in drinks, and they won't make you drunk.

Small amounts occur naturally in fruits and vegetables. The ones in food products are made commercially, mostly from corn or birch (xylitol) or by fermenting glucose (erythritol). You'll find them in sugar-free gum and mints, "no sugar added" chocolate and candy, protein bars, keto snacks, ice cream and toothpaste, and as the bulk in many stevia and monk fruit sweeteners.

On a label, look for names ending in -itol (erythritol, xylitol, sorbitol, maltitol, mannitol, lactitol) plus isomalt.

Sugar alcohols compared

TypeCal/gSweetStomach
Erythritol0.20.7×Best
Mannitol1.60.5×Poor
Isomalt2.00.5×Fair
Maltitol2.10.9×Poor
Xylitol2.41×Fair
Sorbitol2.60.6×Poor
Sugar41×—

Calories are the values commonly used for labeling in the US; sweetness is compared with table sugar. "Stomach" is how well most people tolerate larger amounts.

Erythritol stands out: almost zero calories and no effect on blood sugar, because about 90% is absorbed into the blood and passed out in urine unchanged, so little reaches the large intestine where gas and diarrhea start. Xylitol tastes most like sugar and is good for teeth. Maltitol, common in sugar-free chocolate, is the sweetest after xylitol but also raises blood sugar the most and causes the most stomach trouble.

Erythritol: the most common sweetener in sugar-free products

Erythritol has become the default bulk sweetener because it measures like sugar, has close to zero calories and is gentle on most stomachs. It has a noticeable cooling feel in the mouth, which is why it's often mixed with stevia or monk fruit.

The 2023 heart study. An observational study found that people with higher blood levels of erythritol had a higher risk of heart attack and stroke, and that erythritol made blood platelets more likely to clump in lab tests. A similar finding for xylitol followed in 2024. These studies show an association, not proof that the sweeteners cause heart problems, and the body also makes some erythritol itself. Research is ongoing. If you have heart disease or a high risk of it, it's reasonable to limit erythritol and xylitol until there's more evidence; allulose is an alternative that bakes in a similar way.

Sugar alcohol vs sugar

Are sugar alcohols bad for you?

In normal amounts, no. They're approved as safe by food safety agencies in the US and Europe. The issues are:

  1. Digestive side effects. Gas, bloating, rumbling and loose stools are common if you eat a lot at once, especially sorbitol, maltitol and mannitol. Products with large amounts must warn that "excess consumption may have a laxative effect". Tolerance varies; start small.
  2. They can trigger IBS symptoms. Polyols are one of the "P"s in the FODMAP diet used for irritable bowel syndrome.
  3. They're toxic to dogs. Xylitol in particular can be life-threatening to dogs even in small amounts. Keep sugar-free gum and xylitol products away from pets.
  4. "Sugar-free" isn't calorie-free. A sugar-free chocolate bar sweetened with maltitol can have almost as many calories as the regular one, because the fat and other ingredients haven't changed.

How to count sugar alcohols and net carbs

On US nutrition labels, sugar alcohols are included in Total carbohydrate, and may be listed on their own line. They're not counted as sugars.

For tracking, log the calories on the label; they already account for the lower calories of sugar alcohols. If you count net carbs, the common approach is:

So a bar with 20 g total carbs, 5 g fiber and 10 g maltitol has about 10 g of net carbs (20 − 5 − 5), not 5.

Which sweetener should you choose?

There's no single best, but as a rough guide:

Frequently asked questions

What is a sugar alcohol?

A type of carbohydrate, such as erythritol, xylitol, sorbitol or maltitol, that tastes sweet but is only partly absorbed, so it has fewer calories than sugar. It contains no alcohol.

Are sugar alcohols bad for you?

Not in normal amounts. They are approved as safe, but larger amounts can cause bloating, gas and diarrhea. Xylitol is toxic to dogs.

Is erythritol safe?

It is approved as safe and is the best-tolerated sugar alcohol. A 2023 observational study linked high blood levels to heart risk, which is not proof of harm; people with heart disease may prefer to limit it while research continues.

Do sugar alcohols count as carbs?

They are included in total carbohydrate on US labels. For net carbs, most people subtract all of the erythritol and about half of other sugar alcohols.

Which sugar alcohol is best?

Erythritol, for the fewest calories, no effect on blood sugar and the least stomach upset. Maltitol and sorbitol cause the most digestive problems.